jlvatron: The humans in AvP 1 were sooo much better.
Really?! They just struck me as a completey random assortment of international co-production staffers.
That said, I liked the movie. Sure not as good as the 1st, but I wouldn't expect that anyway, #1 was amazing.
I finally saw Aliens Vs. Predator: Requiem (not sure what was up with that title) tonight on DVD. And while it was not a great movie by any means, I'd say it was markedly better than Alien Vs. Predator, if only because it was so much more faithful to the original movies in spirit, music, violence, action, lighting and peril.
The problem is, while Alien Vs. Predator was too high-concept, Aliens Vs. Predator: Requiem is too low-concept by steeping itself so deeply in homage. It doesn't really do anything new with the franchises, despite finally getting to the 'Aliens in America' premise that had been hinted at ever since Alien: Resurrection.
The alien queen (born from a Predator chest) didn't really make any sense. She only sometimes acted queen-like. And that reproduction method managed to top the accelerated birth syndrome of Alien Vs. Predator in sheer silliness (and lack of faith to what had been established in the earlier films).
I guess the saving grace was going in knowing this would be essentially a typical American slasher flick with aliens and predators instead of Jason and Freddy. If I'd been expecting anything more interesting in genre, I would have been very disappointed ... but the results were significantly better executed than Paul W.S. Anderson's abortion.