Spacecast Community

She is way to goody goody.  And she let the baby cylon live and spared Sharon the way she acts is to fishy for me.

She also spaced a Cylon prisoner, lied to Adama about said baby and seriously thought about rigging an election.

---

I'm Who and I approved this message.

True but the cylons are moving things in a way to do the most damage  to cause the most pain and they are building up to reveal the other five cylons and for some reason I think it is her so does my hubby.  It seems to be building around her and Baltar and her if it is not her it has to be somebody she trusts.  One of the main people 

 

They way the show is my hubby likes the cylons better than the humans

The humans are not honorable cylons are straight forward

LADYWOLFE:

True but the cylons are moving things in a way to do the most damage  to cause the most pain and they are building up to reveal the other five cylons and for some reason I think it is her so does my hubby.  It seems to be building around her and Baltar and her if it is not her it has to be somebody she trusts.  One of the main people 

 

They way the show is my hubby likes the cylons better than the humans

The humans are not honorable cylons are straight forward

The Cylons are straight forward 'cause apparently "they have a plan". That does'nt mean the Cylons are honorable and I am not trying to defend the human species as such,because an attempted act of genocide or extinction by any species is deplorable. However it does make one wonder if two sentient species meet that feel each other is a threat to their own survival what would the ultimate goal be in defeating such an enemy ?  If Ros is a Cylon then she is a sleeper though I doubt at this point that she is , and yes she does seem to have her own agenda at times , but then most people in a position of power usually do. It would not surprise me if the Cylons realize, some already do, that what they are trying to destroy is actually what will save them. ...D   ... a belated welcome to the boards to you

---

...in essence we are the universe
trying to understand itself.

After thinking on it a great deal, since there's always so much speculation about which one of the other established characters are Cylons (it just never ends), I've come to the decision that if they do in fact reveal another of the characters as one, that will be my signal that the show has jumped the shark and has lost it's cred.

---

Kitane:

After thinking on it a great deal, since there's always so much speculation about which one of the other established characters are Cylons (it just never ends), I've come to the decision that if they do in fact reveal another of the characters as one, that will be my signal that the show has jumped the shark and has lost it's cred.

Totally agree with Kitane.  Especially when considering if Roslin is a Cylon.  The two people who absolutely cannot be a Cylon without the whole show self-destructing is Roslin and William Adama. I've already documented my long-winded rationale on who I think could be a Cylon here. 

More reasons why Roslin *cannot* be a Cylon:  (a) She was dying of cancer !! (b) She has been instrumental in waging war against the Cylons; (c) She personally ordered Cylons to be thrown out of airlocks; (d) She was the first or second candidate for Baltar's Cylon Test; (e) She wanted to abort Athena's pregnancy; (f) She was rounded up by the Cylons to be executed with Zarek on New Caprica by Cylon Centurions; (g) She has continuously been trying to expose Baltar as a Cylon (h) Plus, a helluva lot more reasons I'm sure ....
 

It just makes no sense.

---

She is definitely not a Cylon.  As far as we know, no Cylon was ever sick before that one episode.  She had cancer, so that rules her out.  Billy was the Cylon, and he will appear again.  Maybe that holy woman who got killed on Cobol was a Cylon too, I think it is funny that they only had one sleeper again hidden in the church.

Regardless of who it is, its time for the writers to get to it and reveal someone else as a cylon.  I love BSG but I am getting annoyed with the dragging out of who the remaining 5 cylons are.  We don't need them all at once.  Just give us 1 more to satisfy the craving already!  If this doesn't happen in the second half of S3, I will be extremely ticked off.

I don't think any of the other regulars (or semi-regulars) should be revealed as a cylon. It would be very difficult to do that for any of them and not have it seem "cheap". -- Rhys

According to the Sci-Fi trailer for Season 3.5, is that not the direction they are taking this?

Another thing, I have become fairly certain that the remaining 5 cylons are not on the same side as the seven we know about.  No idea what their goals are though.