Spacecast Community

Ok who would win in a al out fight.

 

Now if you combine the Cylons/Colonist(the entire fleet before being deystroyed) against the Galatic Empire of Star Wars with the Rebels.

BSG vs Star Wars

Winner Star Wars.

 

Why The Death Star

No Death Star then it would be a toss up.

 

BSG vs Star trek.

 

Winner Star trek Fleet

 

Why Have shields on their ships and have surpiereor weapons.

 

Star Trek vs Star Wars

 

Winner Star trek, but just.

 

Why Though they have superior weapons the death Star would be hard too deystroy.

 

Your views and picks?

 

TOM

Note to all SpaceCasters....vs threads are not welcomed here,it turns friends into enemies

---

Click The Image
"BRING BACK BABYLON 5"
Elevation 43 feet above sea level

In the big battles.  Star Trek's Federation would take out Blake's 7s Federation.  Earth Force would take out the Galactica crew, since they would have the help of the Anla 'Shok.  Star Wars would crush the combined Dalek/Cybermen/Sontaran fleets.

 

The ST Federation would then easily defeat Earth Force since they have superior engineers, scientists and doctors.  They would not, however be able to defeat the Star Wars force.  Its ships are too big and powerful.  Besides, they have Force users.  The only way the Federation would have a chance is if James T. Kirk and company were put in command of the USS Defiant, NX-74205.  Then they would have a slim chance, although Han Solo's luck would counteract James T.s sneakiness.

 All of this is moot because the Time Lords would never allow it to happen.

---

20 minutes into the future.

It's too late tonight for this, and just can't decide.

Anyway, Borg vs. Cylon would be cool. Yeah, if James T. Kirk was in command of the Defiant, I could just imagine the fury that would be unleashed, LOL!!

 

 

MCIBUS:

Ok who would win in a al out fight.

 Your views and picks?

TOM

The BSG humans (by themselves) vrs Cylons in an actual battle.  The humans win.  Because the Galactica is using museum ships and beating the main cylon fighters, so the more advance human ships would kick metal butt.  

BSG humans vrs the Imperial Navy of Star Wars.  BSG wins.  I wasn't impressed with the Imperial forces. The Death Star was destroyed easily (twice!).

BSG humans vrs Star Trek (I  assume we the federation is meant, as they are the most powerful force on Trek)  BSG wins.  Sorry, trekkers, the energy shields and phasers do not impress me as being superior to the BSG shields and weapons.  Besides, those Star Trek ships have warp-core breaches far too easily.

Star Trek vrs Star Wars Imperial Navy.  Star Trek wins. Similar weapon types.  Close fight. The Death Star would not help, although its weakness might be soley to small-ship attack, and Star Trek fleets have no small fighters. Hmmmm.  But I still give the win to Trek.

 

Lol, Who.  

Star Trek's Federation vrs Blake's 7 Federation.  Star Trek wins this one hands down. 

Earth Force (Is that what the fleet from Babylon 5 was called?) vrs BSG humans.  BSG wins in a tight match.  Similar ideas regarding ships and weapons as I recall (haven't seen Bab -5 in years), but I'll give the edge to BSG because of sheer ferocity of it's fighters. 

Star Wars vrs Daleks/Cybermen/Sontarans.  I can't picture those three nations allying, but all are known more for boasting and losing than actually winning, just like Klingons.  So Star Wars wins.

Star Trek Federation vrs Earth Force.  Earth Force. That type of weapon design impresses me more than the Trek/Star Wars style.  I can hear it now: "Shields at 60%, at 40%, 15%,we have no shields! Warp core breach!  Ahhhh!"

Interesting to mention Star Wars force users.  Earth Force has its PSi-core, a similar idea.  A match between these groups would be interesting.  A toss up ... let's say Jedi Knights beats Psi-corp, but Psi-corp beats the dark side.

And the human warships from Fifth Element.  Only seen briefly.  They are a dark-horse.  I'd say they are about an even match for Star Wars, but would lose to Trek, BSG, and Earth Force.

The Time Lords are off in a corner of the galaxy playing poker with the Organians.

Star Trek does have fighters. You just don't see them often in the show but there was 1 episode in TNG and several in the DS9 that showed big battle were fighters were present. Also a couple of the movies had them as well. You never really got to see them up close but they were buzzing around Borg and Dominion ships as well I believe a fighter was used to attack civilians in one of the movies.

 Then if you play the video games one of them has you playing in fighter around the big ships. So yup they have fighters.

 In the end who'd win. Well I'd say BSG would as they actually are more realistic and as reality asserts its self the fantasy of the other disappears leaving the  competition dead in the water. BSG is still just as fantasy but at least if the fantasy were removed they'd still be viable. Missing artificial gravity and FTL drives still leaves the BSG with an ability to attack and defend.

 

MapleDog:

Note to all SpaceCasters....vs threads are not welcomed here,it turns friends into enemies

 

Why?

 

Its not like its written in stone. And where are these "rules"

 

Its a friendly question amongst friendly SCI-FI fans of all bases.We all have our favorites, and just because one fan favors his favorite of anothe fans favorite doesn't mean there going to get mad fight over a post. After al its just TV and shows its not real.

 

We all have dufferent out comes of such said senerio.

 

Peace Out dude where all friends here.

This is the nerdiest topic ever!

(granted, in the sci-fi world, there's likely been worse, but this is still pretty high up there)

Many millions of dollars profit go to whomever first successfully licenses all of the above mentioned (and related) fleet likenesses, and wraps them into an expansive ONLINE (World of Warcraft type) space roaming adventure/battle universe - thusly allowing all sci-fi fanboys/fangirls to fight for their allegiances, and perpetually try to prove the superiority of their nerdverse.

HURRAH! 

 

PS - For the record, I would play this game as the Borg. Someone please make it.

PPS - Any such game creation would surely be bogged down by fan bickering and arguments regarding "inter-continuity", for example The Federation being based on Earth, while co-existing in a Babylon-5 universe, or perhaps the relation of galaxies location to one another (where exactly is a long time ago in a galaxy far far away anyway).  At least the BSG fandom would get to map a path to/from the colonies to earth.

PPPS - Can someone PLEASE PLEASE make this damn game?  Fromthe nerdiest topic ever came the best idea ever.  Am I wrong? 

Such games do happen from time to time.  The Japanese Super Robot Wars series uses the mechs from a number of anime series.  They rarely make it over here do to rights issues.

---

20 minutes into the future.

Well in an all out war Star Trek wins in space (cylon advantge) BSG wins on the ground  here my reasoning for it

BSG VS Star Trek (Federation) 

Space Combat 

  BSG  Weapons consist of : bullets, missiles and nukes  Amour: umm the metal that they build the vipers with and gallactica 
  Star Trek  Weapon consist of: Phaser, Torpedos, quantum torpedos couple other asorment of high yeild torpedo. Defence they have hull plating Sheilds, and maybe helpfull a tractor beam and of coarse a warp drive (hard to hit something moving faster then light)

Star Wars Weapons:  laser cannons, and missiles cant think of anything else they shoot with. defence there small fighters have r2d2 ( x-wing and nabo fighter) to repair any damage inflicted and the main ships like destroyers have some sort of hull plating or light sheilds they usualy take a beating. 

bonus items BSG none Star Trek none ship are highly powerfull as is and Star wars death star

space battle we would see Cylon raiders and viper and raptors blow to bits by both fedetation ships maybe even some shuttle craft with limited phaser coul blow them away  and  x wing's  shotting there lasers Gallactica might hold out for  bit defenately would keep star wars at bay with the firering solution some well placed nukes could even blow away some of star wars destroyers but eventualy  federation will swoop in with there sheilds up and lay out a torpedo spread to destroy the gelactica if does not retreat that if the enterprise does not warp in close at the begining shooting it to peaces with some quantum torpedo's and the BSG is out fot the all out war federation ship will make quick work of star wars ships after and the battle star either would be beat by some babardment by the federation or if the weakness is the only thing that will let it be destroyed then the defiant will fly in or even the delta flyer small and nimble able to launch torpedo's would take care of the base star seal the fate there(the force does not play a role in the space combat they dont see or hear the jedi in conbat)

now on the ground the difference in weapons does not make a hole lot of difference accept the jedi since it hard enough for anyone from star wars to hit them with lasers the federation will have even more hard time with them even at a vaporizing setting they have not chance and well the force not usefull on the stong minded vulcan's would manage protect the fed from that sort of trickery and for the winner the Colonial forces and the Cylon  well Cylon more the winning factor (or it would have been the jedi the force would be the down fall for the colonial soldiers) for the sheer number of droids they could produce and the amount of ammo they would shell out even the jedi cant block it all and since its not energy weapons being shot they wont be able to resend those round back at the attacker cause those light sabers would just insinnerate the shot they blocked so it BSG on the ground.

its all reasoned out but now if on the ground we removed the jedi and Cylon it would be a completely fair fight weapond would actualy make no diference.

now if the borg where in it at all they win it all just asimilate one jedi and they are that much closer to perfection